Selling New and Used Video Games: What Are Your Games Really Worth?

Selling New and Used Video Games: What Are Your Games Really Worth?

If you’ve ever looked at your stack of video games—old favorites, unfinished titles, or duplicates—you’ve probably wondered: “How much are these games actually worth?”

The answer isn’t always simple. The value of new and used video games can vary dramatically depending on where you sell them, their condition, and how popular the title still is. Let’s break it down so you can make sure you’re getting the best possible return on your collection.

đź“€ New vs. Used: The Big Difference

  • New (Sealed) Games:
    If your game is brand new and sealed, it holds the highest resale value. Collectors and gamers will often pay a premium for untouched titles—sometimes even more than retail if the game is rare or sold out.

  • Used Games in Great Condition:
    Games that are gently used, complete with their original case and manual, will still fetch strong resale prices.

  • Loose Discs or Cartridges:
    These are worth less, but demand still exists—especially for popular franchises like Pokémon, Call of Duty, Mario Kart, and Zelda.

🎮 What Factors Affect a Game’s Value?

  • Popularity & Demand – Hit titles like Grand Theft Auto V or The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild hold value longer than niche games.

  • Rarity & Collectibility – Limited editions, discontinued releases, or games with small production runs can skyrocket in price.

  • Condition – Complete-in-box (CIB) games, with artwork and manuals, are worth more than disc-only copies.

  • Platform – Retro systems (NES, SNES, Sega, GameCube) can sometimes command higher resale value than newer systems, depending on demand.

  • Timing – Games often drop in value when sequels launch, but rare or nostalgic titles can spike years later.

đź’µ Where to Sell: GameStop vs. Local Resellers vs. Online

GameStop

  • Pros: Convenient, instant store credit.

  • Cons: Known for low cash offers—sometimes just a few dollars for games that resell at $30–$40.

Local Electronic Resellers (like Cash4UrElectronic.com)

  • Pros: Pay higher cash values than GameStop, accept a wider variety of titles, and offer same-day payouts.

  • Cons: Availability depends on your area.

Online Marketplaces (eBay, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp)

  • Pros: Potentially highest payouts since you sell directly to other gamers.

  • Cons: Takes time, effort, shipping costs, and risk of non-paying buyers or scammers.

🏆 Real-World Value Examples

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate (Nintendo Switch)

GameStop cash offer: $12–15

  • Local reseller: $25–30
  • Online resale: $30–40

Pokémon HeartGold (Nintendo DS)

  • GameStop cash offer: $10 or less
  • Local reseller: $50–60
  • Online resale: $80–100+ (complete with case & PokĂ©walker accessory)

🔑 Tips to Maximize Your Video Game’s Value

  1. Keep Original Packaging – Cases, manuals, and inserts add significant value.

  2. Clean & Test Games – A working, scratch-free game always sells better.

  3. Sell in Bundles – A stack of games often fetches more than selling individually.

  4. Check Market Prices First – Use sites like PriceCharting or eBay sold listings to know your game’s real market value.

  5. Choose the Right Buyer – Decide if you want fast cash (reseller) or maximum value (online marketplace).

Final Thoughts

When it comes to selling your new and used video games, knowledge is power. GameStop might be convenient, but if you want the best cash offers, local electronic resellers like Cash4UrElectronic.com usually pay much more—and instantly.

At the end of the day, your games are worth more than you think—especially if you know where to sell and how to present them.

👉 Ready to turn your collection into cash? Visit Cash4UrElectronic.com today for a fast quote and same-day payout.

Back to blog

Leave a comment